• Home
  • About Me
  • Travel Advising
    • Travel Advising and Itinerary Design
    • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Travel Blog
  • Publications
  • What I’m Reading

Kayla Smith

May 28, 2024

Why I Did NOT Love Isla Holbox, Mexico

I first became aware of Isla Holbox because I follow their quasi-famous animal rescue on Instagram, and that seemed like enough indication that I would love the island. Refugio Animal Holbox is a no-kill rescue that saves dogs, other pets, and wildlife from all over the island, and they do an incredible job of marketing their volunteer shifts as tourist opportunities. Several of the hostels and hotels in town offer dog walking at the shelter as a unique island activity. After doing a similar tourist-advertised volunteer walk at a rescue in Croatia, I wonder why animal shelters in all tourist hubs aren’t doing the same thing. I am not exaggerating when I tell you that Refugio Animal Holbox was the biggest reason that I wanted to go to Holbox.

Aside from the shelter, Holbox didn’t seem like an obvious place for me to go. As I’ve written before, I’m terrible at beach vacations. I’m so pale I’m practically translucent, and sitting in direct sunlight for more than 10 minutes ensures days of misery to follow. Plus, I’m too restless for beach sitting. I’m not a great swimmer. The combination of sand and sweat is entirely unappealing. A Mayan Riviera vacation would simply be wasted on me.

And yet… It felt wrong to spend three weeks on the Yucatan Peninsula and NOT see one of its famous beaches. And of all the beach destinations available, Holbox seemed like the right one. There were a lot of things that drew me to the island. Most of what I’d read online said Holbox was like Tulum 15 years ago—a still undiscovered gem that you should get to before the masses arrived. There are no cars allowed on the island. You can only get there via ferry, and everyone travels by foot, bike, or golf cart. It’s safe and affordable (or so said Google), devoid of resorts, high-rise condos, and chain restaurants. And there were plenty of activities for a person not interested in beach-sitting. I could take a midnight bioluminescence tour. I could go kayaking. I could go horse-back riding. I could swim with whale sharks! And I could walk sweet dogs every morning and evening. Nearly everyone I know who had been said it was gorgeous. So I booked two nights at a hostel near the ferry dock.

I will confess that a lot of my negative experiences in Holbox were circumstantial. Some of them were my fault entirely. Things started to go wrong before I even left Merida. It was a weekday in the off-season, and it hadn’t occurred to me that the direct bus from Merida to Chiquilá (the town where the Holbox ferry departs from) would sell out days in advance. A wave of dread washed over me when I logged onto the bus website a couple days before I intended to leave and saw that the bus tickets were sold out. I didn’t panic though—I scolded myself for the mistake and bought a ticket to Cancun and then a ticket from Cancun to Chiquilá instead. It cost me a few hours and I had to pay twice the price for two tickets, but it wasn’t a huge deal.

When our bus arrived in Chiquilá, I followed the crowd to the ferry ticket booth where the attendant told me that he didn’t accept credit cards. I had some cash with me, but not enough for a ticket. I’d planned to get cash immediately after arriving. The dread rushed back. There’s no way, I thought. There’s no way that every person in this line knew they had to have cash. I asked the attendant where the nearest ATM was, and he rolled his eyes as if I were the most obnoxious person he’d ever encountered in his life. “On the island,” he told me. “There isn’t one here.”

He waved me aside, and for ten minutes I dug through every one of my bags searching for more cash and furious with myself for not getting cash before I left Merida. I tried to brainstorm plans so I didn’t panic. Maybe I could find an American who had extra cash and Venmo them. Maybe I could offer the ticket guy more money in US dollars. When I got back in line after everyone else had left with their ferry tickets, the attendant looked at me with disgust and pulled a credit card machine from under his counter. “You can use a card, but it’s 5% extra.” I stared at him, dumbfounded. “That’s no problem,” I told him, as if I were entirely unbothered. I’d just spent two weeks in Merida where everyone was overly welcoming and hospitable. The contrast felt deeply depressing. And this was the first indication that many interactions in Holbox would feel like transactional cash grabs.

The half-hour ferry ride to Holbox was lovely, but as soon as we departed the boat, I saw the mud. Despite all the research I’d done, I hadn’t realized that Holbox becomes nearly impossible to navigate by foot after even the mildest rainstorm. I’m not exaggerating when I tell you that the mud puddles were the length and width of swimming pools. There were places where you simply could not get down a street without trudging through mud to your shins. All the roads were dirt, so there was no way to escape it. The standing water invited seemingly every mosquito on the continent. I tried to remind myself that it was silly, privileged, and dramatic to be bothered over some mud puddles. At the same time, I also live in a place that deals with extreme flooding, and in New Orleans, it’s not dramatic to recognize that there is a level of flooding that makes the city inoperable. This was not the case in Holbox.

My hostel was just a few blocks from the ferry, but it took me half an hour to find a walkable route around the mud to get to it. The route involved walking over a rickety little plank that someone propped on some trash. On my walk, I started noticing the trash everywhere. Because Holbox is an island, it’s more complicated to remove trash than it would be on the mainland. And as tourism has increased, the overdevelopment hasn’t been sustainable. The trash had piled up in yards, on properties, around construction, and in random fields.

Do not believe the blogs that tell you this is an undiscovered gem—Isla Holbox has long-been discovered and is catering to a wealthy tourist crowd willing to pay $20 for their morning smoothie bowls while the tiny family home next door looks like it may not have electricity. The shocking inequality and gentrification that I hadn’t visited Tulum to avoid was here too.

It was entirely my fault that I accidentally stayed in a party hostel. I picked a hostel that was part of a local chain I’d also stayed in for a few nights in Merida (Che Hostels) because the pictures looked pretty and it had good reviews. There was no one to blame but me. I had two roommates in my 4-bed dorm—two Australian guys in their mid-20s. They were polite the few times I saw them awake, but they’d leave to go party when I was getting back to the room to go to bed. They’d come back at 2:00am and try to be quiet, but there was no possibility it wasn’t going to wake me up. Their efforts at being quiet didn’t matter anyway. The karaoke and pool parties at the hostel lasted nearly as long, and the door blocked approximately zero percent of the sound.

I joined the Whatsapp group for the hostel when I checked in, and I kept getting increasingly wild group texts from the staff at the hostel. “Hey crazy peopleee Tomorrow we have a big island party we gona make a huge party all the afternoon starting on the boat… gona make some drinking games, music, party, dancing… TEQUILA BOOM BOOM. Are you readyys for that???” Yes, that is a direct quote. And no, I was not ready for that. I’d recommend the hostel to anyone under the age of, say, 22. And only if they are interested in copious amounts of alcohol and loud music. Otherwise, this is the wrong choice.

On my first evening in Holbox, I tried to get dinner and quickly found that the vast majority of restaurants on the island didn’t accept credit cards. Luckily I was able to get cash from one of the 2 or 3 ATMs on the island, even though locals told me that the machine was often out of cash. I was determined to walk a dog from the shelter that evening so that my trip to the island hadn’t been a waste. And I did. Balloo the dog and I trudged through mud up to my ankles to get to the beach. The seasonal algae was waiting for us there, but I didn’t care. My all-natural mosquito repellent did almost nothing, but the sunset was beautiful. Refugio Animal Holbox deserves all the special awards for figuring out how to operate in these conditions and continuously bringing animals to safety. They were my favorite part of the island.

I was determined to have a better day the next day. I started my morning with a smoothie and a slice of banana bread for just $16 (which is to say, more money than I’d pay for the same thing back home in New Orleans). Then I headed toward Punta Coco beach, supposedly the most beautiful beach on the island. I’d checked out the price for some beach activities like horse-back riding and the bioluminescence tours, but they were far out of my budget, so I decided that a relaxing day of island exploration would be the right way to spend my only full day there.

I headed toward Punta Coco on the beach. It was a lovely 30-minute walk before I got to a point where the trees reached into the water and the beach stopped. I turned inland and walked a few blocks before I arrived at my first swimming-pool sized puddle. A girl who’d been following behind me for a while joined me as I surveyed it. We agreed that there was simply no choice but to walk through it. I left my Teva sandals on as we trudged through the mud because I was afraid of broken glass or sharp objects at the bottom. We could see the beach just three blocks ahead of us as the mud reached our knees. I’d walked 40 minutes at that point, and I refused to turn back. But by the time I reached the beach, the sand and mud under my Teva straps had rubbed giant blisters in multiple spots on each foot. The other girl refused to be deterred and went to bake on the beach for a while. I looked at the beach for about two minutes before deciding that was sufficient and I was ready to go back to my room. I took a look at the beach, which was fine but not prettier than any other beach on the island, and then I asked a man at the snack stand how I could summon a taxi back to town. Wait here, he told me, pointing toward a bench. I sat on the bench imaging the flesh-eating bacteria that was undoubtedly creeping through my blisters.

A middle-aged Mexican man named Antonio joined me on the bench, and the snack man asked us if we would be okay sharing a taxi. When we agreed, he pointed 3 blocks away at one of the 4-wheel jeep/ATV things used as taxis on the island. “There’s your taxi,” he said. “Won’t it come here?” I asked. He shook his head and pointed. So Antonio and I trudged together through mud quite literally to my thighs to get to the taxi. One puddle was so deep that we held hands so we could both keep our balance as we stumbled over rocks and crevices we couldn’t see. It felt like a scene in Jurassic Park. And though I could objectively recognize the humor in this situation at the time, I was also certain the flesh-eating bacteria was going to kill me immediately. Once we finally made it to our taxi, we realized that it was sitting at the end of a boardwalk to the beach. If the snack man had just told us, we could have walked ten minutes on the beach and never had to step in a puddle.

Our taxi ride back to town felt like riding the safari ride in Disney’s Animal Kingdom, and at times the mud we drove through was so deep it washed over my wounded feet. Back in the hostel, I slathered Neosporin all over my feet, and I limped around in my shower shoes (Croc flip-flops) for the rest of my time in Holbox.

That night I walked another dog named Salma, ate overpriced and overcooked coconut shrimp, and shopped in a few local shops before watching the sunset with the crowd by the pier. The next morning, I had a delicious (and surprisingly affordable) smoothie bowl alone at one of the most popular restaurants in town because no one else was awake before 10:00am. Then I packed my bags while my roommates were still asleep, eager to get to the ferry as fast as I could. Of course, the ferry I planned to take was NOT the one my roundtrip ticket covered, so I spent about an hour certain I was going to miss my next bus. But I didn’t. I made it on the bus with just a few minutes to spare, very glad to be leaving Holbox behind.

How does one write about a place where they had a bad time while acknowledging that many others would love it? So many people adore Holbox, and as I said, much of what I didn’t love was circumstantial. But it is worth noting the realities of the island like how it is no longer an “undiscovered” paradise and how you should expect high prices. A “car free” island doesn’t mean that it’s lacking in motor vehicles (there are delivery vehicles as well as ATVs and golf carts). You’ll read that Holbox is a place that focuses on eco-tourism and sustainability, but the overdevelopment and trash suggest that this is wishful thinking.

But I would consider going back and doing it differently. I’d love to do a bioluminescence tour. I’d bring a lot of cash. During the right season of the year, I’d love to swim with the whales. I would know to avoid the hostels and stay in private accommodations instead. I’d know to carefully keep track of the weather, both before my visit and during. I’d go back to walk more dogs at Refugio Animal Holbox. And if I had double the budget, I’d enjoy a lot of smoothie bowls. I’ve pet every stray dog I could find. (You can’t imagine how many precious stray dogs are waiting for you in Holbox.)

The blisters on my feet left scars for a couple months, but as you might have suspected, the flesh-eating bacteria didn’t find me after all.

Posted In: Isla Holbox, Quintana Roo, Yucatan Peninsula · Tagged: Animal Rescue, Holbox, Hostels, Isla Holbox

Get on the List

About Me

Writer, educator, book lover, explorer, map collector, and elderly dog lover. Sharing thoughts, stories, and wonder as I go.

Recent Posts

  • Returning to Front Beach Cottages and Why I Recommend Traveling with Your Dog
  • What Writing Letters to Strangers During the Pandemic Taught Me
  • My Favorite Mardi Gras Parades in New Orleans
  • How to Choose the Best Accommodations When You Travel
  • The 15 Best Books I Read in 2024

Archives

  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • May 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • January 2022
  • March 2021
  • January 2021
  • June 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • June 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • December 2017
  • October 2017
  • June 2017
  • March 2017
  • January 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • September 2016
  • July 2016
  • April 2016
  • January 2016
  • October 2015
  • September 2015
  • August 2015
  • July 2015
  • May 2015
  • March 2015
  • January 2015
  • November 2014
  • July 2014
  • May 2014
  • March 2014
  • February 2014
  • January 2014

Join the List

Connect

kaylamichellesmith

During the 24 hours I was in Sarajevo, it stormed, During the 24 hours I was in Sarajevo, it stormed, I twisted my ankle, a tour I wanted to do was canceled, and I lost my debit card. But despite all this, I knew nearly immediately that I was obsessed with this city. 

Sarajevo isn’t the most beautiful place I’ve ever been, but it’s one of the most fascinating. The little I knew about Sarajevo, and the rest of Bosnia and Herzegovina, before visiting was outdated by 30 years. The war here happened so recently that my school textbooks were published before it but so long ago that I barely remember. The first time I ever heard of a place called Bosnia, long before I could find it on a map, was in a kid’s chapter book about the war, and what I took away from the story was that this was a terrifying and dangerous place that a person should never visit. 

What a gift it is to be able to correct your own past assumptions.

When I think about which places I’ve visited that I want to return to, Sarajevo is near the top of that list.
Leaving Budapest and the Schengen zone for Serbia Leaving Budapest and the Schengen zone for Serbia felt like heading into the Wild West—this was a very different Europe than I’d visited before. And to be honest, my first impression of Belgrade was not a good one. We arrived late at night after bus delays, and the bus station was closed. Late night transportation  options were questionable, and taxi drivers kept approaching way too eagerly and offering rides for ridiculous prices. This could have happened in any city, but in the moment it felt sketchy and tense.

The next morning, the city felt considerably less sketchy but still cold and unwelcoming. It took half a day, but finally we found a couple modern and popular areas of town full of bookstores and music and better vibes. And while I still wouldn’t say I liked Belgrade much, I’m glad I visited and glad that I was able to change my mind after my initial impression. And of course, I ended up loving the rest of the Balkans. 

I know so many people who LOVE Serbia. I’d love to go back and explore more of the country to find why they love it.
My monthly reminder that most of my photos are act My monthly reminder that most of my photos are actually dog photos and that I’m at my kitchen table far more often than I’m traveling. August had some lovely moments. @1samanthaaldana  @lindaa.xoxoxo
If you’ve ever wondered what I’m doing when I’m away traveling, it’s usually this. 

(Is there a single one of you who’s gonna watch 50 entires seconds of bookstores? @thebookeasy friends, I’m counting on you! 😂) 

Everyone, drop your favorite bookstore in the world in the comments! I’ll add them all to my travel list! 

I think my favorite of all these is @carturesticarusel in Bucharest. It’s indescribably magical.
For over a decade, countless people have told me I For over a decade, countless people have told me I should pursue a job as a travel advisor. I’m so glad I finally decided they were right. @hellofora 

Nothing brings me as much joy as helping others travel. But Instagram and its mysterious algorithm can only go so far in helping me reach people who want to hear more about what I can offer. So…I’ve decided to start a newsletter! 

In my newsletter, I’ll share special deals, perks, tips, and news for all types of travelers. I am planning to send a newsletter just once or twice per month, and you can trust that I won’t spam you! 

If you’d like to receive the newsletter, you can comment “Me!” below, and I’ll send you the easy sign up link! And I’ll be forever grateful if you help spread the word!
Follow on Instagram

Copyright © 2025 Kayla Smith · Theme by 17th Avenue